Case Study

Case Study

Why I Replaced an Unlimited Automation Retainer With Fixed-Price Builds

· Updated

· Updated

I build custom automations and operational systems for businesses. I began with hourly consulting and freelance projects before trying to put the work into an agency offer. My low-code stack included Airtable, Zapier, Make and n8n; for sales automations and CRM setups, we mostly worked with HubSpot and GoHighLevel.

My first agency offer was unlimited custom automations for a monthly retainer. I signed two clients on it, then both churned about a month after I joined Client Ascension. I realized the offer did not make sense and had to rethink what I was selling.

A recurring fee did not make unlimited builds the right offer

I had been selling unlimited custom workflow builds for a monthly retainer. After those clients churned, I questioned how that structure matched the work I was offering.

With feedback, I moved toward fixed-price packages. Ongoing maintenance and optimization could then sit behind the initial project rather than requiring every build to be sold as an unlimited monthly service.

Maintenance needed its own pricing decision

Luke Ward helped me think through pricing for the maintenance work. After that conversation, I closed a client on a maintenance retainer.

That was a specific addition to the service. It did not mean every project automatically became a long-term retainer or that all clients needed the same ongoing arrangement.

Client Ascension related reading: Connor’s HubSpot operations account describes narrowing a technical service and improving the way it is presented to prospects.

Organic content had done most of the acquisition work

The business had grown mainly through my organic content. I had not taken cold email seriously enough to describe it as the engine behind that growth; I was working on it next.

At the same time, I was improving the sales process, the fixed-price structure and fulfillment. There were several parts of the business to work on, rather than one new acquisition tactic explaining everything.

The sales-and-delivery cycle kept repeating

I kept moving between sales and fulfillment. I could close a group of clients, stop selling while I completed their work and then find myself needing to restart the pipeline.

Shen helped me hire fulfillment support so the business did not have to operate that way. I valued what the team could do and said I could not fulfill as well without them.

Client Ascension related reading: Max’s delivery-handoff account describes hiring and training someone to take on client work.

The next step depended on the current constraint

I said clients were staying longer, I was generating more case studies and the pipeline was full. I was still busy and taking calls; having fulfillment support did not mean I had stopped working on the business.

Monthly goals and accountability with Shen helped me focus on what needed to happen next. My advice was to use the calls relevant to the stage of the business and implement the feedback, instead of treating more training as the same thing as progress.

Adapted by Client Ascension with AI assistance from Luke's interview. The first-person narrative follows the source speaker’s account. Watch the original video