Case Study

Case Study

How I Built a Cold-Email Agency Team While Running a Second Business

· Updated

· Updated

I was still in college while running a cold-email agency. When I began, I handled the work myself; by the interview, I had built a team of four and was also working on a second agency with a partner.

Andre introduced the first agency as being around 15K–17K a month and the second around 20K–25K a month. Those were separate business revenue ranges discussed in the interview, not my personal earnings or profit. I also worked part-time at ListKit, Andre’s software company, so the conversation included that employment relationship.

I asked other owners how to use the support well

After joining, I messaged people I had met in the community and asked what had helped them get value from it. A common answer was to attend the coaching calls.

For a period, I went to as many as I could. That exposed me to sales, copy and content feedback while I was still learning the different parts of running the agency.

Cold email improved through repeated script tests

Cold email was the channel I had relied on most from the start. I brought scripts to Christian and Nile, wrote different versions and tested what worked.

I also posted on Twitter about insights from doing the work. I said that brought a few clients too. Sharing useful experience became another source of conversations, alongside outbound.

Client Ascension related reading: James’s cold-email agency account describes acquisition and adapting onboarding around demand.

I learned sales structure rather than relying on being outgoing

Being naturally extroverted did not mean I already understood a sales-call structure. David Jacob’s calls helped me with questions, psychology and how to handle the conversation.

I submitted calls for feedback, including criticism I needed to hear. I reported closing roughly thirty to forty percent over the previous month or two; that was my recent self-report, not a benchmark every agency could expect.

Operations became the most important new skill

I had started like a freelancer, handling the back end myself. Building a four-person team made the work feel more structured, and I used the operations material and hiring feedback to help bring people on.

I described operations as perhaps the biggest skill I had gained. Selling more work would not remove the need to manage the people and processes delivering it.

Client Ascension related reading: Angel’s recruiting-agency account describes team management and day-to-day operations.

The second agency fit an existing skill set

My partner and I had met at the Tampa event, stayed loosely in touch and later began working together on an idea that fit outbound and go-to-market skills. We had been teaming up for about three months at the time of the interview.

The ListKit role came from a message in Slack. I wrote a lot of scripts and wanted to contribute while learning from a larger operation. Watching the team’s thoroughness and how people were motivated gave me things I wanted to bring into my own smaller team.

Adapted by Client Ascension with AI assistance from Ryan's interview. The first-person narrative follows the source speaker’s account. Watch the original video